There's something rather appealing about having two sizeable 4x4s at your disposal, a handful of Yorkshire green lanes to explore and absolutely no particular reason to be anywhere in a hurry. Well, apart from the rapidly disappearing November daylight, obviously.
To coincide with the recent INEOS Grenadier weekend, INEOS kindly loaned good friend Andy a Grenadier for a week or so. Meanwhile, I had Volkswagen's Amarok on test, which presented us with a perfectly good excuse to get together, find some lanes and see how the two very different 4x4s got along.
It's practically the law
My plan was to tackle a collection of lanes around Buckden, before heading over towards Colsterdale and picking up a few more favourites along the way. There was also another important consideration. One of my other firmly established laws of Yorkshire green laning is that, if you're anywhere near the Buck Inn, you simply have to stop for a fish and mushy peas butty.
Some traditions are worth preserving.
With the route plotted on the Garmin Tread 2 and What3Words loaded on my phone (because I still don't entirely trust the Garmin), we set off from Harris Towers in Settle.
An hour or so later, we arrived at the Buck Inn, only to discover that it was firmly closed.
Disappointment doesn't really cover it. My stomach had been issuing increasingly urgent reminders of the planned lunch stop, and the prospect of a fish and mushy peas butty had been keeping me going for the best part of an hour.
Still, there's no point letting a closed pub ruin a perfectly good day out. Although I reserve the right to sulk.
A tight squeeze on Morpeth Gate
Our first lane was Morpeth Gate (SE0287-03, Trailwise 2 reference), tackled from west to east.
It's a fairly narrow affair to begin with, squeezed between two stone walls, with loose stones and gravel under the tyres. There are a few steeper sections as the track winds its way upwards, but neither vehicle showed any concern about finding traction.
Both the Amarok and Grenadier made light work of it.
That was until we rounded a particularly tight corner and discovered a fallen tree sprawled across the lane.
Thankfully, somebody, presumably the local farmer, had already taken a chainsaw to part of it, leaving just enough room for a vehicle to squeeze through. And I mean just enough.
The photograph really doesn't do the gap justice. There was considerably less daylight between the vehicles and the remaining branches than I would have liked, but with a bit of careful positioning, both made it through without donating any paintwork to the local forestry industry.
Continuing along SE0287-03, we joined High Lane (SE0388-06 and SE0487-03), which is a rather different proposition. The narrow, enclosed track gives way to a much wider, compacted gravel surface, punctuated by several fairly deep puddles.
Naturally, we made the most of those. There's little point taking a couple of capable 4x4s out for the day if you're going to avoid the water.
Colsterdale and a new challenge
From here, we headed towards Colsterdale, a journey of roughly an hour, during which both What3Words and the Garmin managed to agree on where we were going.
A minor miracle, really.
I've had the Garmin Tread 2 for a few years now, and while it undoubtedly has plenty of capability, I still find it unnecessarily complicated. There seem to be an awful lot of functions, menus and options, particularly when you're accustomed to the simplicity of Google Maps, What3Words and Trailwise on an iPhone.
It's a subject deserving of its own review, which I'll hopefully get around to writing at some point. In the meantime, What3Words remains my insurance policy.
Eventually, we arrived at SE1280-02, a lane I'd not driven before.
It has a reasonably solid base, but don't let that lull you into a false sense of security. There are some substantial ruts along the way, making decent ground clearance rather important. Both vehicles coped well, although the Amarok did introduce its underside to the occasional high point. Nothing particularly alarming, but enough to remind me that a pickup isn't always the most delicate of vehicles underneath.
The lane itself wasn't especially long, but it certainly provided an entertaining combination of surfaces and weather.
And what weather.
We had wind strong enough to make opening the Amarok's driver's door something of a workout, glorious sunshine, driving rain and, at one point, all three seemingly happening together. The reward was a rather spectacular double rainbow stretching across the landscape.
A lovely sight, although I suspect neither of us was particularly interested in getting out of the vehicles to admire it for too long.
There were also plenty of gates. Enough, in fact, to give the day something of a cardiovascular element, particularly if you're the one volunteering to get out and open them.
Underneath the tyres, conditions varied considerably. Some sections offered a reassuring stone base, while others were little more than slippery, churned-up mud.
On one particularly greasy stretch, I discovered just how slippery things had become. Even when using engine braking, the Amarok continued to slide forwards in slow motion as I eased off the throttle. It was one of those moments when you realise that gravity and a lack of traction are having a rather more significant influence on proceedings than your right foot.
With a gate approaching, I gently steered into the existing ruts, allowing the tyres to find a little more purchase and bring the vehicle under control.
It did the trick, and we continued without incident.
Moorland views and a familiar favourite
Next on the itinerary were SE1878-03 and SE1776-08, a stony, rough track that climbs towards the open moorland before joining Wreaks Lane (SE1474-02).
Wreaks is one of my favourites, and it's easy to see why. The scenery opens up, the views stretch across the surrounding countryside and, provided the weather is behaving itself, it's a cracking place to spend a bit of time behind the wheel.
Although the weather had been doing its best to demonstrate every possible November condition, we were fortunate enough to get a few brighter spells.
The enormous timber pile was also impossible to ignore. It would have been rude not to stop and take a couple of photographs, particularly with two rather photogenic 4x4s sitting nearby.
The lane itself has a good, firm surface, although some seriously deep ruts have developed over the past year. They're worth keeping an eye on, especially if you're travelling in a vehicle with less ground clearance.
Neither the Amarok nor Grenadier had any real difficulty, but it was another reminder that familiar lanes can change considerably between visits.
A fuel-related change of plan
As we approached the end of the lane, Andy came over the radio with some potentially unwelcome news.
The Grenadier was showing just 50 miles of remaining range.
With another couple of lanes still on the itinerary, followed by an hour or so of driving home for him, it seemed sensible to abandon the original plan and find some diesel.
The nearest convenient option was in Pateley Bridge, around 20 minutes away, so we pointed the two vehicles towards civilisation.
Following Andy in the Grenadier from Lofthouse, past Gouthwaite Reservoir and towards Pateley Bridge, gave me an opportunity to watch the Grenadier working along some of Yorkshire's narrower country roads.
And I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised.
Andy doesn't exactly hang about, and watching the Grenadier negotiate some of the tighter bends at a reasonably brisk pace was interesting. Given its height, solid axles and coil-sprung suspension, you'd perhaps expect it to feel a little cumbersome or wallowy when pushed along twisty tarmac.
It didn't.
The Grenadier appeared remarkably composed, with a stability and handling balance that made it look considerably more agile than its dimensions might suggest.
Of course, I was following rather than driving it, so I wasn't experiencing everything from behind the wheel, but from where I was sitting, it certainly looked comfortable making progress along those narrow roads.
What about the Amarok? Even unladen it handles the long straights and tight bends with ease - just as a modern pickup should.
Two thirsty six-cylinders
By the time we'd reached Pateley Bridge, filled up and considered the remaining daylight, November was rapidly getting the better of us.
With another two lanes originally planned, we could have pushed on, but neither of us fancied finishing the day in the dark, so we decided to call it a day and head our separate ways.
Andy had around 30 minutes to get home. I had a rather less appealing journey of just over two hours.
There was, however, one final surprise.
After a full day of fairly brisk country-road driving, a reasonable amount of low-range work and plenty of stop-start green laning, both vehicles had returned remarkably similar fuel figures.
The Amarok's 3.0-litre V6 TDI and the Grenadier's 3.0-litre straight-six diesel had both averaged somewhere around 22-24mpg.
Not exactly miserly, but considering the size, weight and type of driving we'd been doing, we were both pleasantly surprised.
And so ended another Yorkshire mooch. Two big diesel 4x4s, a fallen tree, slippery mud, spectacular weather, one rather disappointing pub and a double rainbow for good measure.
We didn't manage all the lanes we'd planned, and I never did get my fish and mushy peas butty, but that's green laning for you. Plans change, weather happens, fuel runs low and occasionally a tree gets in the way.
Still, there's always next time.
And I'll be checking the Buck Inn is open before setting off.