Ditch Gas: Go Electric for Safer, Smarter Camping
There are a couple of things that has prompted me to write this article…
The first was when, in the middle of cooking my breakfast whilst camping, I ran out of gas. Not too bad if I was staying in a campsite, but I was in the middle of nowhere. Yes, you can argue that it’s my fault for not being prepared, and I’ll agree with you, it was 100% a school boy error.
Then there is the constant, and ever-increasing cost of replacement cartridges. Maybe it’s because I’m Northern, or maybe it’s my age, but there are certain things in life that I don’t really want to pay for anymore, like water that falls from the sky, and energy with which to cook with.
Yes, I understand that at home I have to pay for this stuff - the infrastructure and staff to look after it are necessary, but lining the deep pockets of shareholders, nah! In truth, we pay too much for a lot of things, so saving money here and there can mount up.
So what’s my point?
Well, as the title suggests, when it comes to camping, I’m going electric. Using electric instead of gas for camping and cooking purposes brings about several advantages - convenience, safety, and environmental concerns (yes, yes, I know I drive a 4x4!).
While gas has been a traditional choice for campers due to its portability and familiarity, electric camping hobs are gaining traction for several compelling reasons....
Safety & Convenience:
Electric hobs eliminate the need for open flames, reducing the risk of accidental fires, especially in dry or windy camping environments. They don’t emit harmful gases or fumes, making them safer for use within confined spaces like tents or small camper vans. Additionally, there's no need to worry about gas leaks or carrying pressurised canisters, enhancing the overall safety aspect of camping.
In terms of convenience, electric hobs offer a more user-friendly experience. They often feature precise temperature controls, allowing for more consistent and even cooking. Some models are portable and lightweight, easily fitting into a camping kit. Also, many electric hobs can be powered by various sources such as portable power stations, vehicle 12v systems (if wired up correctly), or solar generators, providing flexibility in power supply.
Environmental Considerations:
Electric hobs are generally considered more environmentally friendly compared to gas, especially when you consider all the energy and costs that go into gas exploration and drilling. Then, as a collective, we have to deal with the release of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases when gas is burned. Electric hobs on the other hand can be powered by renewable energy sources like solar or wind power, significantly reducing their carbon footprint. Using your own solar panels or charging using electricity from sustainable sources promotes a greener way of enjoying the outdoors.
Then there’s the question of how to dispose of those small gas canisters?
Definitely do not place them in recycling bins, as local authorities are very strict on this. A spokesperson said:
"We routinely see propane tanks of all sizes in the Materials Recycling Facility, exactly where they should not be. Propane tanks, even the small butane campsite-styles, are not recyclable in curb-side bins. They usually have trace amounts of gas in them, and when compressed will explode."
This then causes a problem of where to take them as recounted by a member of a popular climber's website...
"I took them to recycling facilities in both Liverpool and Warrington, and both refused to take them, as they don't have the license. I called both Cotswold and Go Outdoors, who suggested the local recycling centers (see above). In frustration, I tried Coleman, who referred me to local recycling centers, saying they should take them if they have a gas cage (again, see above). I have called Liverpool council who put me in touch with a contractor who will take them for about £5 a go plus £30 collection fee! Warrington just don't take them at all. Short of throwing them into a well known outdoor gear stockists camping display, how am I supposed to get shot of them!"
So, not only are they expensive in the first place, they can also be expensive to get rid of.
Cleanliness & Maintenance:
Electric hobs typically offer easier cleaning and maintenance compared to gas stoves. They often have a smooth, flat surface that is simple to wipe down and keep clean.
There are no gas burners or grates that need to be scrubbed or maintained, or fiddly gaps that food can fall through, simplifying the clean up process.
Cooking Versatility:
Like gas burners, electric hobs come in a variety of types and sizes, offering a range of cooking options. Induction hobs, in particular, offer rapid heating and precise temperature control, allowing for efficient and quick meal preparation. Some models have multiple rings, providing campers with the versatility to cook different dishes simultaneously or handle various cooking techniques.
Consistency in High Altitudes & Cold Temperatures:
Gas stoves might struggle in extreme weather conditions, such as high altitudes or cold temperatures, affecting their efficiency. On the other hand, electric hobs generally perform consistently regardless of altitude or temperature variations providing a reliable cooking option for campers exploring diverse terrains and climates (though for off-grid I realise keeping batteries charged in freezing temperatures can also be an issue),.
Is there a downside?
Switching to any new power source can mean investing in new products, like pans that are suitable to use on induction hobs.
Check before you go out and buy new gear as your existing pots and pans might already be suitable. For example, my Vango Cuisine collapsible pots have a stainless steel base so are great for induction hobs.
Looking at buying a new kettle? Why bother, if you have the space simply take the one from home and plug it into your power station, if it’s powerful enough of course. Alternatively, a low wattage electric kettle like the Kampa Squash or Quest Braunton can be had for between £20-£30.
In conclusion, while gas stoves have long been the go-to choice for camp cooking due to their portability, electric hobs offer several advantages in terms of safety, convenience, environmental considerations, cleanliness, cooking versatility, and consistency in challenging conditions.
As camping technology advances and environmental awareness grows, the shift towards electric presents a compelling option for modern campers seeking a safer, cleaner, and more adaptable cooking experience in the great outdoors.
What do you think? Are you going to stick with gas or are you also changing to electric?
Let us know in the comments below.